Milillo Pizzeria in Hamilton

Old world pizza flavor.

Good local pizza restaurant

Food is amazing! Great customer service!

A Hamilton historic staple that has been in business since 1968. A wonderful meal guaranteed every time you visit! We absolutely love it!

First time ordering from here. I got the lasagna and came with a HUGE garlic bread! The lasagna was so tasty and lots of cheese..just how I like it! My hubby got ravioli..he said was yummy!The next week we tried their pizza..ordered a LG 🍕 pizzaIts was tasty..toppings onions and Italian sausage was so good. We definitely will always go back for their mouth watering tasty food!Great portions too!Service was great.

On a scale of 1 to 10 where 1 is bad and 10 is the best I rate Milillo's a 15

My favorite pizza.

best pizza in Hamilton. One of the best in SW OhioI've taken away one star for two reasons: the wait here is always longer than what they tell you. It's worth the wait. But when they say it'll be ready in 35mins and you show up 40mins later and they tell you it's another 15min wait, it's annoying.Second, as I sit here waiting, a customer's pizza was made wrong. Lady proceeded to tell him to listen better and that it was his fault. They remade his order. Then when he left, all the workers started badmouthing him while customers are waiting. Just really unpleasant to listen to while I waited.

Their pizza is delicious!

We decided try Milillos on our way back to Indiana, and glad we did. The pizza was very tasty and the employees were sure nice. Plus chocolate chip cookies yummy

They are so friendly! Love the flavor and the crust! We got the pizza with all the meat, so we did blot some of the grease off. What a nice treat for my brother who came to visit from out of town. 🙂

Best pizza in Hamilton or any place else!! Don't miss out.

Finally a cauliflower crust pizza! And it is yummy!

Good pizza but very pricey!

This pizza is one of the best in the area. Great sauce! You will not be disappointed with this place.

The best pizza and homemade pies. The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly

We have lived in the area for almost three years and somehow, had never tried Milillo’s....until last night. WOW! My husband and I were so impressed. The service was great and the pizza and calzone we got were outstanding. I grew up on NY style pizza and calzones and these remind me of them! The flavor and quality are not like your cheap, commercialized pizza. The pizza was loaded with cheese and the calzone was HUGE. The prices were super reasonable considering the quality and quantity of what you are getting. The perfect, hole in the wall pizzeria...we will definitely be returning!

A great local pizza joint, their pies are also first rate.

Been a loyal customer since 1979 for a reason. Great food. Still the cheesiest pizza in town and my favorite sauce. Their pasta dinners are really good too, we love the lasagna. They also have great salads, the best side salad anywhere because of the cheese. Consistently great food, good service, a Butler County treasure

Best pizza place in town. Been coming here since I was a little kid.

Ordered the pie via phone. Was ready coming out of their oven right on time. Cooked to perfection. My wife and I quickly devoured it when I brought it in to the house.

Love eating here. I like Milillos pizzas better than Richards pizza. Their 🍕. I recommend their deluxe pizza

Very worth the drive, make sure you get their garlic butter. I'd eat it everyday if I lived closer. The staff enjoy what they do. They make you feel like a regular.

Love everything great. Steak sandwich, pizza.

I live in KY and I have eaten their pizza for the past 40 years when visiting family. I highly recommend them.

Their Pizza is the Best! Love the cheese they use!

Always a must to have Milillos when I come to Hamilton OH. Great salads, including antipasta, pizza's, sandwiches, and desserts. The tiramisu is superb.

Great food and friendly staff also big supporters of the 4-H program in Butler county.

Absolutely delicious 😋😍🙌It was definitely worth the wait

So good. Service is great. Best pizza in and around Hamilton

A Hamilton family tradition, have many memories or going here with Grandma, really great pizza and steak hoagies. Mmmmm Italiano

I get one every week...The Best..Its Real..............

Excellent home made pizzas!

Our absolute favorite pizza since the 70's! No one else's cheese or sauce compares! Only carry out & no delivery, but worth the drive every time!!! Try their lasagna... It's five star hands down!

Best pizza ever

Is very delicious, just a little over priced but all n all great

I mean look at that bread perfection

I've been eating here since I had teeth or before. Get an Italian Delight (well done, so the roll gets a little dark) with extra sauce. This is the best sandwich I've ever had, and I've had them all.

I've loved this place since I was a kid so happy to be so close now!!!

I had just one of the most sweetest moments calling in to make a order and a little girl answered the phone and about melted my heart 🖤🖤🖤 thank you for a cute amazing experience. This was a first for me and caught me off guard but I couldnt have been more please. This seriously made my night!

We had pizza and meatball subs it was delicious. Real Italian

I had milillo's pizza for dinner last night for the first time! One of the best ❤️ pizza's ever!

Amazing food. Always hot and fresh. Breadsticks are absolutely wonderful. The hot Italian sub is my go to.

Been going there for years. Its the only phone number I know by heart. Best pizza ever. The epitome of a mom and pop pizza place. Awesome staff too. Patronize our local businesses.

Great food and service

My favorite pizza place ever.

Best pizza in Hamilton Ohio, hands down! A must try! But, I really don't get it why, when you google "pizza near me", it never shows up in the results?

Pretty good pizza if you've been stuck on the normal Papa Johns, Pizza hut, Dominos, and Little Caesars. Milillo's Pizza tastes more like a homemade pizza. A little greasy for my liking since I started trying to eat a little healthier but grease can be blotted with a paper towel. I will have to say the crust was very delicious and didn't taste "airy" like other pizzas. It was dense and tasted like it was meant to be a part of the pizza.

Taste like home, the old school type pizza

Really amazing homemade recipe pizza, just like I remember! The real deal, folks. Worth every penny. Highly recommend if you are sick of chain restaurant pizza and want something true and authentic.